Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sociotech 4895 days ago
I don't know anything about the Smith case, and I am not saying you (and Cullen) are wrong to draw the comparison and ask questions about it.

However, it is very difficult to make this kind of backseat-driver judgment. I'm not arguing that people shouldn't look into it. They should. But different cases are often treated very differently. Perhaps Smith's case would have been harder to prove to a jury. Perhaps he had better procedural objections. It doesn't just come down to how bad anyone thinks the crime is.

1 comments

At least we seem to agree her office should be investigated as to how they handled the case. It's not acceptable to me that they just be allowed to slither away by issuing a press release absolving themselves. My point is his 'alleged' crime was less offensive to the public good, and a misdemeanor conviction in Aaron's case should've met the prosecutors need for a 'crime' such as this (which was nowhere near as offensive as ballot rigging). Why insist on guilty plea to 13 felony counts unless you are being a hardass &trying to build a name for yourself?