[Garoof]

Note that my response was mainly to the "hard to understand because questionmarks" part of your post. I think that's a pretty weak argument, and that being clear about which part of the code depends on the ifs easily makes up for weird syntax or whatever. The "that is goofy, this is mature" stuff is ridicilous.

I get that there are other reasons for sometimes choosing if-statements instead of if-expressions in cases like this. But then it quickly comes down to a bunch of technicalities (language can't do this, debugger can't do that, ...), and really, even if we're talking C++ stuff only I would not agree with it as general advice.