Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by martinced 4904 days ago
I'm tired of the logical fallacy that consists in always saying: "Every software suffers from security issues".

It is just plain wrong to reason like this.

So let me ask something to the ones using the above fallacy: are all programs (say webservers) equals in the face of security?

It's an easy question right? And the answer is: "no, they're not all equal".

So stop saying: "But Java had several DoS bugs affecting Tomcat in 2011 too, so we're not doing anything wrong here".

And start coding (and documenting) to higher standards.

1 comments

You make it sound as if "Every software suffers from security issues" was brought up as a reason not to put effort into security. It was not.

It is very valid to reason within constraints of reality. Like knowing that a car "which will never ever have an accident. ever" is a lie. We know that driving a car brings a risk of an accident. That is realism. Some turn that reality into dangerous behaviour. Saying things like "Statistics tell me I will have an accident no matter what. So I can just as well finish this bottle of whiskey before driving at 150Km/h home". You are making it sound as if the Rails developers follow that logic.

They don't. There simply is a certain realism that, no matter how much effort you put into security, there will be security issues. But nothing more. Or less.