[gleitz]

An enhancement I've been considering is noticing when users ask for a second or third answer with "-p2" or "-p3". If it happens often and the user never queries again after reading the second answer you can assume it is probably correct and display it to all users as the default response.

[nicpottier]

Also.. don't you think the more common case is not that the top answer is incorrect but rather you picked the wrong question from the search results? Seems to me that would be more common.

[gleitz]

Ah yes I should clarify. -p2 picks the second search result from Google, not the second answer to the question.

$ howdoi format dates django templates -l

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/7737146/django-template-d...

$ howdoi format dates django templates -p2 -l

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1180372/how-to-format-dat...

$ howdoi format dates django templates -p3 -l

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/4087717/django-template-d...

Another improvement might be to list the second and third answers to the currently selected question.

[voltagex_]

maybe howdoi --reroll? (Repeat same question for a second opinion)

[davej]

That sounds smart but it also means that you'd need to keep track of and store user actions centrally. I don't know if I'd like that. You could always make it an opt-in feature I suppose.

[nicpottier]

That's not a bad idea, kind of meta level answer tracking.

What about making it even easier by just prompting as to whether it answered their question? (perhaps defaulting to 'y' so you can just hit enter if so)

[catshirt]

not necessarily. usually if i am on stack overflow i am looking for an easy-type answer. usually if that is not one of the first two, i move on.