Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dexter313 4916 days ago
Looks silly to me, like an oversized controller with a mini tablet stuck on top. I don't see how that is portable, unless "portable" doesn't mean you can put it into a pocket anymore.

I guess it's a nice prototype but this won't make it to the shelves in this form.
1 comments
potatolicious 4916 days ago
> "I don't see how that is portable, unless "portable" doesn't mean you can put it into a pocket anymore."

Portable gaming has never had pocketability as a core requirement. The original Game Boy was way too big for pockets, as is the PSP, and to a lesser extent the Nintendo DS. The closest we really got was the Game Boy Pocket.

Portable gaming has always been about devices that you can whip out during a plane ride, bus ride, train ride, or in a waiting room without it being unwieldy and awkward - this seems to fit that bill. The 5-10h battery life also helps considerably.

link
cube13 4916 days ago
Form factor is still important, though. The handgrips can catch on stuff in a bag, which is an annoyance.

Compared to a tablet, phone, or any of the current portable systems, it's a lot thicker, too. That can make it a bit unwieldy to keep in a bag.

link
potatolicious 4916 days ago
You're right, but it's also why I think Nvidia's idea can work.

This product is not competing with tablets and phones - that market has been lost long, long ago. After the rise of smartphones Nintendo's entire portable market vanished very quickly. Casual gamers are no longer interested in carrying around (and paying for) a purpose-built gaming device. When you want to blow away 15 minutes on the bus you won't ever pick a Nintendo DS or PSP over your phone or tablet.

The remaining bit of the mobile gaming space is strictly hardcore, and that's currently underserved - there are a substantial number of gamers who want a mobile device that can actually play console-class games. The only player in this space right now is the PSP, and the execution on that device is poor enough to warrant new competition in the space.

A device with great battery life (good enough for a plane ride), a solid selection of games, and most importantly, a solid modern software platform (read: Steam-like), would do well. The only portability requirements here are "fits in your bag".

link