Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lanelio 4917 days ago
"I haven't read the article but..."

So it's come to this on HN...

3 comments

I routinely read through the comments before I actually click on the link to the article. It's a quick indicator to the quality of the article and often, I learn more from the comments vs. the article itself.
I used to do the same thing until I realized how much it affected my interpretation of the article. It colored my thoughts, making me part of the hivemind. Now I read the article first, then wait a few seconds before looking at what other people think so I can better for my own opinion.
That's the problem with the HN:News iOS app - it shows the comments first and I've always believed it should show the article first.
Very much yes. I need more up votes to give. Why on earth are comments first, maybe comments first AFTER the first viewing, but not first time.
Reading through the comments before reading the article is different from posting your thoughts without reading the article.
No.. it was just stated instead of not.
Somewhere between 50-75% of the time I don't read the articles posted to HN. The comments are frequenty more interesting, and almost always have commenters that are more informed about the original topic.