Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by vitovito 4912 days ago
Nope. Either way, speech synthesis isn't the hard part; having natural cadences and useful things being said is.

The less your animatronic creature does, the greater you project your own emotions onto it, and more likely you are to find it realistic or compelling or interesting or natural. Poor robotic speech instantly kills that empathy. Think about R2-D2's nonsensical beeps (that express emotion tonally) versus C3-PO's obnoxious prattling.

If you're trying to make it be "helpful" by telling you status information, how many times have you been frustrated when someone gives you directions, or is telling you about a problem narratively instead of in terms of reproducible steps? Speech is very inefficient, but for empathizing, Furbish was great.