[justnoise]

I wanted to post this last night but the internet went down in Vientiane (again) so I just went to sleep.

Having spent the last couple of months connecting from various parts of SE Asia, I'm happy to see this getting the attention it deserves. You don't realize how utterly painful or unusable much of the web is until you experience a network that is not only incredibly slow (by US standards) but also incredibly unreliable and prone to 5-20 minute outages many times per hour or day depending on where you are.

Before today, I hadn't clicked on a youtube video in months. The site was unusable.

Most evenings in smaller cities (not villages, that's a different story entirely) the broadband will be OK with downloads averaging around 3-15KB/sec. This allows you to access most sites or check gmail (usually I still opt for HTML mode). However, it's the frequent and intermittent outages that cause the most headaches. In many places I've visited they happen a couple of times per day and in other places, they happen many times per hour. These outages are a larger problem for AJAX heavy sites where clicking a button doesn't give a page saying "This webpage is not available" instead, the site just sits there, waiting for the request to complete, giving the user no indication that the rest of the internet is unreachable.

I have no idea what causes these outages (it's not the local network) but they lead to an awful experience on some sites. Hacker News, Wikipedia and other places do a great job of providing useful info that can be retrieved in a reasonable amount of time, countless others are so fat I've stopped visiting them entirely.

Think about the people and parts of the world you'd like to reach and design your site to have an enjoyable experience in those areas. I'm grateful for features like gmail's HTML only mode. I only wish other heavy sites had an equivalent feature.

[vii]

I agree that browsers should make it much clearer that clicking on a button or link which does nothing is having no effect. In my mind this violates good UI design: that whatever action the user takes, they deserve some feedback. There are many very popular sites (including Facebook, at which I am advocating for new approaches) where pages are essentially unusable until JavaScript has loaded but little indication is given to the user.

The other point that the Internet is slow and high latency in foreign countries: true, but in the SF Bay Area it's slow and high latency on mobile devices and this should be a common experience shared by Hacker News readers.