[jjr]

But a dict is a list of paired elements? I do like the fact that you can convert freely between string/list/dict. It removes a lot of boilerplate type conversion. Want to serialize a dict? In most languages that's boring code. In Tcl it's so easy you do it all the time.

[skoob]

> But a dict is a list of paired elements?

Not really. A dict is an unordered set of keys where each key has a value associated with it. If you try to access a dict as a list, you might expect to get a list of key-value pairs or a list of values or possibly a list of keys. And in what order will the elements in the list be?

[schlenk]

Tcl dicts are ordered, so you have a defined order for this. http://www.tcl.tk/man/tcl/TclCmd/dict.htm#M27

[keypusher]

Depends on the language, but I prefer the Python approach here. Python is a dynamically (but strongly) typed language. If you want a list from a dict, get a new list via casting ie. list(the_dict), or get a list from either side via the_dict.keys() or the_dict.values(). Weakly typed languages that will do implicit type conversion for you such as TCL and Perl seems prone to mistakes and confusion from this stuff as code complexity of the project grows. I don't think Python gets it right here either though really, as in the end explicit types save so much headache and stupid bugs by finding problems for you at lint or compile time.