Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by halJordan 16 hours ago
It's actually insane to me that the nation convulsed over the inability to get water to flint Michigan and people are still over here doing "no one actually deserves water, you use too much of it anyway"
2 comments

And let's not forget:

> Agriculture accounts for about 80 percent of consumptive use in the United States

https://www.nifa.usda.gov/topics/water

Maybe if we're worried about running out of water, we should prioritize getting the water we do have to actual people. Could the problem be that we're trying to grow avocados in a literal desert? Nah, it's the dang citizens taking too many showers again.

Are you one of these broadminded people who are about to destroy the Peruvian economy and genocide their people because you heard on tiktok that an avocado in the Peruvian desert takes eight gallons etc etc ... while the alternative is applying the half ton of fungicide it takes everywhere else. This is by the way the first desert irrigated, ~5000 years ago, with the same water, by the earliest state in the Americas, growing cotton for export.
I'm not sure what Peru has to do with anything. TFA is about the USA, and usda.gov is an American site.

But I bet if the average ancient Peruvian had to choose between their avocados dying or their next-door neighbors dying, they'd choose to save their neighbors. Unfortunately in modern times, I'm not so sure anymore.

Peru is the home of desert irrigated avocado. It is a leading factor in the total economy, following techniques already known to their ancestors 5000 years ago, but with their cotton not with Mexican avocado.

There were no avocados until quite recently, and thus no choice. There was only uninhabitable desert - though it had once been inhabited and indeed constituted the first known state in the Americas.

Your idea is 'i heard about desert avocadoes on tiktok and its insane and whoever does it needs machine-gunned.'.

Chill. I've never used tiktok. Don't assume everyone you talk to saw the same meme you did.

Did you know more than one country grows avocados?

Apple to oranges. The problem with Flint was lead in municipal pipes, and it has been fixed since forever ago. The majority of US water usage is agricultural and that is only really an issue west of the Mississippi. They are completely separate concerns supported by completely separate infrastructures.