Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hungryhobbit 13 hours ago
This guy is defining himself into a corner:

>GitLab is capable, but it feels incredibly corporate, even more so than GitHub.3 Nor have I found it as good as GitHub at helping people stumble across projects and developers.

So it's not enough for an alternative to do everything you want ... it ALSO has to look "not incredibly corporate", and it has to bring millions of users to your project. Otherwise it's not viable.
3 comments
no_wizard 13 hours ago
It’s really another way of saying: it needs to meet GitHub’s current utility and functions today.

And one of them is ease of discovery. GitHub make’s it really easy to do that. Same with contribution.

As far as looks go? That’s more subjective.

But the discovery and contributions piece is easy to prove, just look at how much traction a project gets when it’s hosted there versus elsewhere. Even really large projects that has many contributors have moved there like WebKit

link
hungryhobbit 13 hours ago
Right, I'm not saying "there are no differences between GitLab and GitHub". They have all the same core functionality, but obviously GitHub has a unique community with more OSS folks.

What I'm saying is, you could pick almost any popular Internet site, craft your requirements to describe it exactly, and write a blog post lamenting how there's no alternative.

It doesn't mean there's really no alternative (for you or anyone else) ... it just means you're announcing to the world that you are a big fan of that site, and you personally will never be happy with any other site no matter what.

link
otterley 13 hours ago
> And one of them is ease of discovery. GitHub make’s it really easy to do that. Same with contribution.

At the end of the day, this seems to be the author's ultimate decision factor. None of the alternatives--open-source, self-hosted, or commercial--have the social gravitational pull GitHub does. Popularity begets popularity.

link
hirako2000 13 hours ago
I share the feeling though, by corporate I believe what is meant: does not cater to public communities.

GitHub was community first, then enterprise. MS hasn't managed to ruin that.

link
dietr1ch 13 hours ago
found the vanilla dvorak user (?)
link