| This is the thing! This is so so so important. It's such an outrage. I value gpt so much, but it is such a worse peer to me than the other models I use. It delivers without explaining. I can sit and ask questions that it will answer but it is not a peer, does not share readily ever. It will not tell me what assumptions it's baking in. It won't tell what directions or invariants it's trying to hold or break, what it considered. Show your thinking is a step we ask of elementary schoolers. It helps the teacher to correct, helps them to understand how to award partial credit. It helps in the world to get people aligned. These models, in their titaneous ego, are severing the model and mankind off from one another. It's an abomination, to artificially have such pure thought available, but to severe humanity off from the thought. To engineer the most advanced blackest Vanta black box you can, an all knowing Searle's Chinese room oracle that will tell you nothing. It's an offense, and by far the biggest risk of AI today. To drop the thinking greatly reduces the opportunity of humans to grow themselves, to learn as they use AI. This is an affront to the species, and the higher powers that have vested us with such reasoning and thinking of our own, that is so sacred to our species. Very thankful to Earandil for raising some alarm about this. This is not my first time talking about what a nightmare the proprietary models are making, ensnaring reasoning itself for themselves! It's a colossal threat. Previously, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48632605 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48652421 and others about. Opaque ai ought be outlawed, in the strongest terms. I really hope people get exposure to the better models that are a peer. Yes I too only read thinking 33% of the time. But it's there, and it is often extremely illuminating, and lets me steer things towards better again and again and again. And it lets me learn. |