Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by BenFranklin100 1 day ago
I’ve sat through enough city public hearings to know what the author claims isn’t true.

People don’t care if the building is gorgeous; they will still oppose it simply because they hate new homes in their neighborhood. If making the building beautiful significantly helped getting through zoning reviews, developers would have figured this out long ago.

Aside: the reasons new buildings are bland is because no two people agree on what is ‘beautiful’; second, delays due to zoning and endless regulations already make it difficult for a project to pencil even before spending much money on the facade.

2 comments

> I’ve sat through enough city public hearings to know what the author claims isn’t true.

> People don’t care if the building is gorgeous; they will still oppose it simply because they hate new homes in their neighborhood.

I read enough of the article to know what you claimed they claimed was not what they claimed. The 2nd paragraph said Ugliness is probably not a major driver of opposition to development by local people. But there is strong circumstantial evidence that ugliness is sometimes a major driver of opposition among people who live nowhere near the development in question.

Many buildings are not ugly and not gorgeous.

> Aside: the reasons new buildings are bland is because no two people agree on what is ‘beautiful’; second, delays due to zoning and endless regulations already make it difficult for a project to pencil even before spending much money on the facade.

New buildings are bland or ugly because this costs less. Everyone's lists of beautiful buildings would differ by 1 at least could be true but is not relevant. It is impossible to design a building most people would not say is ugly would be relevant but is not true.

It's pretty frustrating to see the downvotes for someone who has actually been to housing hearings, something I doubt most people on this site have taken the time to do.

This statement is accurate, too.

You find NIMBYs on Hacker News as well unfortunately.
Also a greater proportion of introverts and misanthropes.
It's almost as if people showed greater respect for those people, the trend would reverse.