Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ahoka 2 days ago
Einstein wanted to measure how fast Earth moves through ether as his research thesis.
3 comments

For those unaware - the most famous experiment to measure this(both high school and university physics classes have drilled this into my brain): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelson%E2%80%93Morley_exper... a long history of experiments failing to find evidence of an ether https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tests_of_special_relativity
This is false, not his research dissertation at all, ... during his student years he did consider the design of a luminiferous ether experiment that he then believed would differentiate an ether world vs a non-ether world.

Of course his views (and most everyone elses) evolved when Lorentz derived the Lorentz transform on grounds of a physical argument, and pointed out that Maxwell's Equations were maintained their form after such a coordinate transform, in gravity-free universes (simple linearly related inertial systems).

When Einstein developed his special theory of relativity, he rejected the putative measurability of the ether in flat spacetime metrics.

Because the ether does exist, when considering the wider world of non-flat spacetime metrics.

You could say Michelson-Morley compared 2 horizontal axes (which are rotation symmetric with the gravity vector). Variations of predictable ether effects are perfectly measurable, when comparing horizontal with vertical paths!

It's different when you invalidate your own research.