[dev0p]

Gemini is the only LLM I've ever experienced that decided on its own to tell me that something was a bad idea. Which, ok, in itself it's not a bad thing, we actually need more of that instead of the pathological sycophancy that all current models suffer from.

But in a physical robot? Yeah, that thing is going to punch me in the face, eventually. Or worse.

[CapyToolkit]

I use Sonnet and Opus everyday. Believe me, it's very common they tell me that something is bad idea, write a rationale and suggest better solutions.

Gemini doesn't remember almost anything after 2-3 follow ups. I have to paste the same "system prompt" at the top of each message and it still doesn't understand it.

[dev0p]

> Believe me, it's very common they tell me that something is bad idea

In my experience, the most they dare is to suggest better alternatives, which is the polite and useful version of telling me something is a bad idea.

But in general, they do not tell you "this whole idea is complete bogus". So far, only Gemini did. Don't even remember what about.