[beardyw]

As evidence you refer to your own site?

[tanker_war]

Stuff like this is why I always read to the bottom of the comments.

People on HN are really something.

[red-iron-pine]

bots? or "engineer's disease" writ large? you be the judge

[julienreszka]

so? it’s open source you can reproduce the research findings. i did the research so don’t claim i don’t know the subject

[mmmmbbbhb]

Did you ask an ai to critique? Gemini have some points that weren't addressed in the post (which I barely skimmed), here's the summary of summary of summary:

Omitted Variable Bias: Conflates development stage with state size. Developing nations have small governments and high catch-up growth; mature economies have large safety nets and slower frontier growth.

Bad Extrapolation: The power-law model predicts ~36% growth at 0% spending. In reality, 0% spending means a failed state with no property rights or rule of law.

Lacks Basic Controls: Ignores panel fixed effects, reverse causality (Wagner's Law), and bundles productive infrastructure with welfare transfers.

[julienreszka]

it’s addressed in the artixle but probably gemini has not large enough context windown the article is pretty long (30min read)