Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Lerc 3 days ago
Why must this result in less joy.

Chess has utility in only the most abstract sense, yet people enjoy it.

Computers became better than humans, and some dispared, but more still enjoy it.

Computers provide insight into the problem, which leads to a greater enjoyment for many people. Instead of finding a move in a complex state and thinking 'I'll never know if that was the best move'. A good chess engine can give a reasonable suggestion of what the best move actually was.

It does take from you the feeling of being special.

We are no longer the only world in existence, we are no longer the center of the universe. We are no longer crafted by a all powerful benign being to be exactly how we should be to rule this world. We are no longer the only things that can play a good game of chess.

That hurts a sense of pride, but I'm not sure it was a worthy sense of pride.

2 comments

> Why must this result in less joy.

The parent's point is better articulated as: programming COUPLED with being paid do it is what is now less enjoyable due to AI.

You are free to enjoy pretty much anything but you may not necessarily be paid to do it.

> We are no longer the only world in existence, we are no longer the center of the universe.

Nothing has changed in this regard. We were the centre prior to AI then we still are after it. The human ability to comprehend makes us the centre. The squiggle: 8 means nothing to an ant but to a human it is the number eighth. AI is something only humans comprehend beyond that what does AI matter and to whom would it matter to?

> why must this result in less joy

Well I think you answered it:

To become a developer, I disciplined my mind to do impressive and useful things. The resulting feelings were pride and speciality and therefore sometimes joy.

And those feelings are gone now that software engineering has become a low-discipline, low-barrier to entry activity.

Am I immoral or vain for having derived joy from that -- I think is another matter, and one which doesn't resurrect the joy no matter how it's answered