Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by carlosjobim 10 days ago
It depends on what your situation would be and where, when you go back in time. Most people in the world today live in absolute misery, so that's not much argument. The enormous abundance of game animals in the past is just one factor which is mostly forgotten today.

In a world without clocks, no electric lights are needed. The safest and highest quality drinking water comes from springs and streams, still today. Flush toilets aren't needed if you live rurally. And so on.

Not to forget, that the less you are used to comforts, the more physically and mentally fit you will be as a person.
1 comments
bluGill 10 days ago
Game animals were rarely that in abundance. It happened after plagues but then populations rebounded and life was a constant struggle.
link
carlosjobim 10 days ago
You've been told that life was a constant struggle, you weren't there. Many would say that life today is a constant struggle.

But we have abundant evidence in art, architecture, inventions, and every fruit of human creativity, showing that people weren't in a constant struggle.

Especially, we have evidence in literature from the past, giving a more nuanced picture than that of constant struggle for everyone everywhere.

link
bluGill 10 days ago
Literature only happened in agricultural societies and mostly by the elites. While it gives us a picture historians have to work really hard to read between the lines to figure out what life was really like for most people. If you were the elite in any time your life is much better than typical.

Many would say life is a constant struggle. However few have any clue what others experience is like. Even the filthy rich consider life a struggle.

link
carlosjobim 10 days ago
> Literature only happened in agricultural societies and mostly by the elites.

How far are you going back now? I'm not for groping in the mists of pre-history, when we can read literary descriptions from the last 500 years. That is a more relatable past than the little we can know from ancient days.

> If you were the elite in any time your life is much better than typical.

Yes, and that is just as true today.

link