Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lovich 14 days ago
> The EU creates new laws…

> If tech companies blatantly break established law then of course they should be punished. However that's not what is happening most of the time, it's new regulations to constrain US tech.

Can you define the word “law” and the word “regulation” for me. You are using them interchangeably while arguing that they should be treated different so I can’t understand your argument beyond a strawmaned version of “I don’t like their laws so it’s not ok”.

I rather engage with the steel man version of your belief so please give me one.
1 comments
villish 14 days ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulation_(European_Union)

"A regulation is a legal act of the European Union which becomes immediately enforceable as law in all member states simultaneously."

I think it's fine that I used the terms interchangeably but you can disagree if you want. Pick the term you prefer instead.

Also, I didn't say "I don't like the EU's laws/regulations". I'm stating that they do target US tech with NEW laws/regulations and the result is large fines. A lot of the time they are wrapped up in a PR package about competition and after years of this, Europeans still prefer to use US tech.

link
lovich 14 days ago
> I think it's fine that I used the terms interchangeably but you can disagree if you want. Pick the term you prefer instead.

This is what you said most recently

> If tech companies blatantly break established law then of course they should be punished. However that's not what is happening most of the time, it's new regulations to constrain US tech.

This is what you said originally that makes a distinction between law and regulation.

I truly cannot understand what you mean if you cannot define these as separate definitions but treat them like they are separate definitions.

Please help me square your world view.

link
villish 14 days ago
The only distinction I made was between established and new. It truly doesn't matter at all if I use both law and regulation even in the same sentence.
link
lovich 14 days ago
So your only problem is that the laws are new and regulating American corporate actions, not the laws itself?

What is your cutoff timeline for where it’s an established law vs a new regulation?

link