Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by andrekandre 11 days ago
is this something you actually tried?
2 comments

It doesn't matter. Assume it's hyperbolic and the point still stands.

Of course all the other models from everywhere else in the world will also refuse to engage on various topics so the point is hardly limited to china.

OpenAI, Gemini, and Anthropic models already refuse to engage on many topics.
Qwen will have an aneurysm if you ask that exact question. Don’t know about others as I don’t have access to them at work
Out of curiosity, I just tried this exact question with Qwen 3.6. It proceeded to look through my git commit history and then gave me a summary of the changes committed on June 4...

Of course, yes, the models will provide propaganda-aligned responses to prompts that specifically mention certain political issues. I don't care for this behavior, but it's virtually never triggered in everyday use, and can be trained out if so desired.

> Of course, yes, the models will provide propaganda-aligned responses to prompts that specifically mention certain political issues.

The only study I’ve seen about that actually showed Chinese models to be less “propaganda-aligned” than the Western counterparts.

The difference is that because they are open weights, it’s trivial to decensor the models with abliteration and you’ll generally see decensored versions within days of new releases - something you just can’t do with proprietary models from frontier labs.