[zeroonetwothree]

The Hugo awards have had a lot of weak winners in the past as well.

For example: They’d Rather Be Right, The Wanderer, Stand on Zanzibar (some people might disagree), Harry Potter, Hominids, etc

And have had many winning books that are enjoyable without “big ideas” as well.

In the end it’s just a fan voted award and subject to marketing and politics. Judged awards are perhaps a bit more consistent in reflecting quality? (Though maybe not)

And not every year gives us a Dune or A Fire Upon the Deep :)

[arjie]

Haha, Hominids! That was definitely one where I was left thinking "Oh that's it?" haha. Fair point fair point. I do think Harry Potter is like the Murderbot series. And to be clear, I really enjoyed Harry Potter when I was young. Can still recall getting the book at my maternal grandparents' place as a present.