Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ButlerianJihad 13 days ago
> mainstream psychiatry never supported nor endorsed

Oh, but they most certainly do!

The Chemical Imbalance issue was always the first and last and best explanation from the lips of the psychologists, psychiatrists, pharmacists, researchers, friends and family. All who unanimously urged me and others to take medications that would somehow magically resolve these imbalances and thus put me and my mind on the straight-and-narrow. And that was the be-all, end-all of treatment. Correct the imbalance and inherit the kingdom, unambiguously!

It still is. The myths continue unabated. Don't try and make it past-tense! Nobody can tell them that it’s junk science. It sells pills and it sells hospital admissions and it sells followup visits. How could it possibly be wrong?

Sometimes in my medical questionnaires, I write "lithium deficiency" or "fluoride deficiency" to remind those fucking superstitious zealots about their idiotic pseudoscientific religion that they mindlessly follow. Jesus never wanted this. In fact, Jesus warned about these false prophets and magicians.

It has fueled DSM diagnoses, it has fueled prescriptions and insurance payments, and it has driven hospital-based rehabilitation like no other therapy before or after it.

1 comments

While I certainly sympathize with your distaste for certain institutions and traditions within the medical industry, I feel compelled to share that you do seem -- if ever so slightly -- imbalanced.
That seems like a high horse you’re on, how did you get up there?
It’s all in good fun, brother. One has to have some awareness of how unhinged they are (and yes it does take one to know one).
It had better be all in good fun—-or else
I mean...from "superstitious zealots" to follow Jesus in the same line is a sign that something is not working and it isn't all in fun, right? Would you expect zero ongoing issues to arise from years of pharma-funded tough love messaging?
FWIW, I took the Jesus stuff to be "part of the joke."
You said I was on a high horse, I said I was just having fun.

Now you're just agreeing with my original assessment? What do you want me to do? They seem like they've got a handle on it.