Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by chopin 17 days ago
Governments will track with whom you verify. Much worse.
1 comments

Can we not spread nonsense narratives? One of the explicit requirements of the EU age verification system is that they cannot:

https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/factpages/blueprint...

First, the user downloads the app onto their phone and sets it up by certifying their age. This can be done with a biometric passport/ID card, a national eID (e.g. national ID Card or other electronic identification mean), a pre-installed third-party app (e.g. a banking app), or in person (e.g. at the post office). Only the information confirming that the user is over the age will be saved in the app. No name, no birthday, or any other data is saved.

After completing this step, the communication between the app and the provider certifying the user’s age (e.g. eID, third-party app) ends. No further data is exchanged.

https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/faqs/eu-age-verific...

The app will likely have access to a bunch of unique identifiers on the phone. At least on Android whichs core concept is spying on the user.

For me, it's enough that your activity could be linked to any unique identity. I don't want mandatory government apps on my phone, that's very chinese. We should strive for better.

Edited to add: your linked FAQ conveniently leaves open how the communication between the web site and the app happens. There are myriad of ways that ones behaviour leaks in this step.