[timcobb]

Does anyone have a theory for what causes Claude to speak this way? A few months ago OpenAI came out with a bit on "gremlins". It's strange IMO that Anthropic hasn't addressed how irritating, dare I say oppressive, Claude can be. Codex is a breath of fresh air. I hope they fix it soon. If product folks at Anthropic think it's charming, it's not, it's terrible.

[NichoPaolucci]

I had a VP of engineering that loved to use “abstracty” engineering terms like Claude uses. Perhaps he was operating one level above what everyone else was doing.

Loved to use fancy words, speak at a “conceptual” level. Unfortunately it was mostly just tech mumbo-jumbo and he couldn’t actually back it up with real work - but I wonder if that’s why Claude does it. Makes it seem like a higher power, hand wavey abstractions that “seem” correct but don’t actually need to be rooted in truth or detailed.

“That’s exactly the type of seam we need to prepare for in a prod-like environment, if this change lands in the data plane, we’ve effectively shut down the load bearing critical path that was needed. It’s not over-engineered; it’s the right thing to do.”

Thanks Claude, whatever that means.

[Terretta]

Fairly certain it's when its confidence level is too low on the right word, it hits a stock phrase instead.

When you see the metaphor or euphemism or simile is off, the selection is not quite apt, it seems the stock phrase or term is rather more probable however askew than the precise phase, and it was already low confidence about what it's trying to say, so – as it's never said – Bob's your uncle.

"Honestly/honest" is, um, absolutely (ahem) one of those and if one listens carefully, one will notice humans use "Honestly? Blah blah…" that way as well.

It taps into load-bearing speech to prop up (see, that works) unsupported claims.

All the words I just used are correct in that sentence, doing exactly (ahem) the work they're supposed to. It doesn't have that level of nuance, isn't sure, so tries to sound like what's probably right.

They're a verbal shrug.