[munksbeer]

It depends on what you think "the right thing is".

Our right thing sounds different to your right thing. Our right thing is PRs less than 500~ lines, and a single logical change only if the overall goal is complex.

For example, in your "right thing" it sounds like you'll have a refactor commit somewhere in the chain of commits in your PR, that might introduce 2000 lines of change, and other logically coupled changes in the same PR, all resulting in a large PR.

We prefer smaller, complete, mergable PRs. And therefore we normally only ever start with a single commit in the PR because the dev squashes everything before raising.

I don't know which way is better, but I do know that when I come across large PRs, I zone out and review quality drops. In fact, I just don't approve them.