Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Papazsazsa 14 days ago
The focus on children needing their phones controlled is the correct instinct, incorrectly applied to a too-narrow group.

Smartphones are fomes peccati.

1 comments

> Smartphones are fomes peccati.

Smartphones aren't, some apps on them are.

(besides being unneeded or a nuisance in some situations)

I have said it for a long time. Look at the original iPhone release. It was a hyper focused device that was designed to consolidate devices, make using a phone easier so that you could get on with your day.

Once the app store and opened the gate for social media to wonder in, that is when these things got turned into potential addiction machines.

It already had a browser. You don't need an app when you have a browser. The addiction is built-in as a latent capability.
The browser itself is not the problem, but the way the platforms design themselves to be very addictive.
> very addictive

The "addictive" insisting by 2 new ones in short time? Getting bot vibes. "We need to classify social media as an addictive substance" more or less. Is that from someone's e-safety commissioner? Or someone wanting back-pay compo right back to MySpace addiction. An absurd idea.

"Some people can't control themselves around video games therefore video games bad", that's what social media has copped.

"Addictive" might mean a bloody well designed user interface that users like. Making buttons easy to access and responsive feedback and just the right amount of visual cues and spicy labels, all in harmony as designed and delivered via well engineered mechanisms. "Too addictive, you must now jump through regulatory hoops". No!

No, I don't think that it's about buttons and scrolling. It is simply about what the algorithm promotes. If you look at one thing, even if you decide that you don't like it, they show you more to provoke you. The algorithm should be limited to showing followed pages.
This is delusional. Normal people have been calling social media addictive since before facebook existed.
I mean, that's just saying it's 3rd party developers who are the fault.

Like SM companies