Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Y-bar 15 days ago
I can’t emphasise enough how much you are missing the point of the law! The law requires me to NOT track you unless I get specific, informed, consent.

The fundamental and default part of the law is to NOT track. Tracking by default (opt-out) is illegal. A modal is just a way to annoy you until you consent against your will.

https://gdpr.eu/article-6-how-to-process-personal-data-legal...

1 comments

> unless I get specific, informed, consent.

Explain how you'd do that without a banner or similarly annoying UX

I don’t know where to begin explaining UX to someone who struggles with the basic concept of consent.
It’s simple, informing implies taking screen space, expressing consent implies user action. So overall it HAS to be similarly annoying to a cookie banner.

Of course if your answer is “people should just stop using cookies” then I have bad news for you.