Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ggm 18 days ago
And my point is that it's a label on a cyclical trend. But sure, he wanted to reason about romanticism specifically. He cuts off very early in the new century, and the romanticism presaged a 50year cycle of revolution and revolt against the congress of Vienna. The tide swung back and forth.
2 comments

>And my point is that it's a label on a cyclical trend

Not so sure about that. Romanticism isn't related to Millinarianism conceptually or otherwise. The former was a re-adoption of a hollistic medieval stance on life and nature.

If you mean "some cultural things change every now and then, so a trend changing is nothing new", maybe, but it's a much smaller claim than that we see a rebirt of Romanticism specifically.

I'm not convinced Beethoven had contemporary groupies tossing him their muffs.

Liszt, however ...

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisztomania

* (NSFW?) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=peJ_ncxXung