Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by antonvs 15 days ago
None of your statements give objective conclusions, unless one accepts as premises the implicit value judgments and other subjective assessments they depend on.

It shouldn't surprise you to know that there are people who disagree with everything you're saying. Do you really believe they're all "objectively wrong"? That's the territory of religion - "only my beliefs are the real ones".
1 comments
teamonkey 15 days ago
Merriam-Webster says:

“Excessive: exceeding what is usual, proper, necessary, or normal”

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/excessive

The power use of data centres is objectively exceeding what is usual or normal. Therefore it is objectively excessive.

link
antonvs 15 days ago
"Usual, proper, necessary, or normal" for what purpose?

For data centers, none of those adjectives are being exceeded, so it's not excessive. Ireland is not using more power to run its data centers than anywhere else is, for data centers of a similar size.

To justify the claim of "excessive", you need to define some standard against which that's being measured. That choice of standard is necessarily subjective.

Again, this attempt to reframe subjective claims as objective is an act of either ignorance (not understanding what "objective" means) or zealotry (believing your opinions are the only ones that can be correct, and therefore "objective".) Either way, you need to examine what you're claiming more closely.

link
teamonkey 15 days ago
I posted several metrics by which the power used by these data centres is ‘excessive’.

You’ve decided that those don’t matter and you’ve created some other metrics by which you could consider the power use typical.

But just because you’ve found a way to say that they’re typical in one way, that doesn’t mean they’re not excessive in another way. They do use power to excess in some ways, therefore it’s perfectly legitimate to describe them as excessive in that way.

Data centres’ power use is becoming a problem for multiple reasons. The problem isn’t going to be solved by denying that a problem exists, or by taking offense when an adjective is used that draws attention to said problem.

> zealotry (believing your opinions are the only ones that can be correct)

Indeed.

link