Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Animats 21 days ago
(2025)

Doctorow has a book-length version of this, "The Reverse Centaur's Guide to Life After AI", which I just read. It's not one of his better works. It's all conventional anti-AI wisdom. Too much of it is about the impact of AI on the punditry and writing industries. I expected better from Doctorow.

I would have expected more focus on the relationship between AI and power. Doctorow has been down that road in his fiction. There's worry about government oppression, but government oppression has been around for most of recorded history, and probably peaked with East Germany. What he doesn't get into is how AI empowers corporations to be more obnoxious. Which is strange, because he's been into that in his fiction. See his "Unauthorized Bread".

One thing AI does is to make corporate control of individuals cheaper. The classic Big Brother peaked, as mentioned, with East Germany, where about 10% of the population was involved with the Stasi. Only a government that didn't have to make a profit could do that. Corporations couldn't go in for that level of surveillance because it wasn't cost-effective when it was labor-intensive. With modern surveillance technology to collect data, and AI to analyze it, it now pays. See Flock, Google, etc.

2 comments

Does anyone know what incentivised citizens to cooperate with the Stasi?
They were arguably the most repressive secret police regime in the world. They disappeared people and their families, and used torture, intimidation, and the biggest network of informants ever assembled (in some cities almost 20% of the population were informants!).

People collaborated because they had to, on top of the usual reasons for joining a military or intelligence service.

Probably the same as for ICE today.
Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil

Hitler's Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust

Ordinary Men: Reserve Police Battalion 101 and the Final Solution in Poland

Popular Opinion and Political Dissent in the Third Reich

The Stasi and the Nazis were two different groups in different time periods. I am only wondering about the Stasi.
The core is the same - totalitarianism.
Same list of things that compels people to become an asset for any intelligence agency, adjusted for the time in history.
is there any good ai book worth reading ? I dont mean things discussing building a tranformer or whatever . I mean like high level ones.
Heard good things of Empire of AI By Karen Hao