Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by aubanel 18 days ago
Probably a great decision, but why/how can it be decided at a local level by a mayor, instead of a federal level?
3 comments

Any jurisdiction can pass a law unless there's a law against doing so.

For example, you couldn't do this in Massachusetts. A city would first have to petition the state for a new law allowing the city to pass such a local law.

I don’t think it would be a federal concern, but a state one.

However, in this case it’s because NYC law is typically allowed under NY state law to be stronger (but not weaker) than any corresponding state law.

NY law already requires easy cancellation https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/GBS/527-A?utm_sour...
Yeah, this is why I highlighted “stricter, but never weaker.”
why: because the federal level is not doing it

how: by declaring it a law in that area

And yet an executive action is not a law. It's a dictate.

Course, one should never underestimate the value of a benevolent dictator...

okay, I apologize for using the word law. However, that doesn't mean they cannot ban it by executive action.