[tobr]

Is the alphabet really the same though? I don't feel like I recall it one letter at a time, as individual facts linking A to B, then B to C, etc, but more as a sound or a phrase. Not unlike recalling a melody. It just seems very different from figuring out what band someone is describing.

[vinceguidry]

Ask someone to name all fifty states, see how far they get. Then start naming places and ask if they're a US state or not. One of these tasks is far more likely to get a 100% hit rate.

[dryarzeg]

Not that I'm too sure about how this applies (or whether it applies at all) to other people as well, but for me personally it's easier to recall information about the band if I'm being told the band's name instead of being told "well, they are known for coloured ties". So, there is certainly some kind of effect described in action.

Now, about alphabet: again, I think it's only me, but when I try to recall it backwards, I can't do that easily. I mean, I can recall it backwards, but I need more time to do that. It's harder. I'm not sure if it's because A links to B, B to C, then C to D and not backwards, or maybe just because in school you learn alphabet from A to Z and not from Z to a - so you're kind of trained to recall it A-->Z way - but it's certainly harder for me.

At the end of the day, though, I think that everyone thinks differently. Everyone is having different internal representations for concepts (such as alphabet), so it’s not surprising that this effect may work differently for different people, or not work at all.

[tobr]

After writing the comment I thought about it some more, and realized when asking myself the question ”what letter comes after R?”, I didn’t immediately know the answer, but I heard ”MNOPQRS” in my head which gave me the answer. So I feel like I know it because I know the rhythm and sound of saying those letters in sequence.