[Avicebron]

> and membership is a signed record they each carry, not a question they ask a server.

Sigh..

I like the project though. It looks very similar to something I vibed up recently, must be in the air

[winterqt]

What’s the sigh to, out of curiosity, just because this makes revocation hard?

[Borealid]

The grandparent comment is correctly pointing out the sentence is an LLM tell.

"Membership is a question they ask a server" is a bogus sentence. "membership" is not a "question". It's syntactically valid semantic nonsense.

"Membership is dictated by a server" is one of several human sentences saying what that one is trying to.

[mintplant]

Going from starting the project two weeks ago to already having a flashy marketing site is another tell, unfortunately. As much as I would love to see a trustworthy version of this idea.

https://github.com/rayfish/rayfish/commit/c49816e6dfba19e91a...

[dfish]

Actually the flashy website was built 4 years ago by another person. We actually tried to build it 4 years ago, but other ventures with higher upside kept our focus. Now you get a VPN for free, no strings attached, although it is vibecoded you still complain :cry:

If you dont like it dont use it

[Avicebron]

Partly. Partly because using EUF-CMA pins the record to the CA which makes membership deniability non-trivial which I don't love. It's not dumb, it's what Signal uses AFAIK and in transit message deniability is different than the signer. But still..

Also that sentence structure is very claudelike.

[dfish]

English is not my mothertongue, therefore I told Claude (and GLM-5.2) to improve the wording as much as they could.