Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by odie5533 25 days ago
Essentially all commercial apple trees are grafted and don't reproduce true to seed. Been this way for almost a century now.
2 comments

It's been that way forever. No apple reproduces true to seed, period. 400 years ago, if you wanted another of your apple tree, you grafted it.
Them doing it for a certain amount of time does not make it any less egregious. I'm not sure if you're just stating fact or wanting to use it as a rebuttal. I hope the former.
The reality is that it’s not as clear cut like “X is bad/Y is good” as laypeople in this thread assume
Apples don't breed true.

You plant a seed, you have very little idea of whether the apples will be good. This isn't a modern evil, this is simply how apples are.