Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by vjulian 26 days ago
There comes a time when voting becomes silly and ineffective.
2 comments

That's the kind of mindset that helps lead to that situation.
Voting isn't some vanguard against political corruption. Voting can and is easily manipulated with completely legal means.
Not voting does absolutely result in political corruption.
Both are not logically exclusive assumptions
This is the kind of mindset that has no grasp of the true nature of power and the political system.
So you rather do nothing than something?
No quite the opposite. It says everything that you think the only alternatives are voting or nothing.
Voting is always effective.

In the worst case it communicates the magnitude of dismsissiveness while demonstrating your intention to claim agency.

In the worst case it generates symbolism; that is ultimately what you’re saying.

That symbolism is akin to prayer.

I am not casting prayer in a negative light, I’m simply categorising your voting concept.

Sure, but...

Visibly praying in public would be symbolic. Prayer is not symbolic; it's thought.

I'm talking about external signaling.

In the worst case the true count is never revealed and the vote is coopted.
Ah yes, voting is always effective. Thank goodness people in Germany kept voting in the early 1930s. Imagine what terrible things might have happened if they hadn't.
Agreed.