Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ruszki 30 days ago
The parent commenter rightfully criticizes these kinds of sentences:

> Necessity being the mother of invention, this led to the creation of an ingenious solution: daisugi, the growing of additional trees, in effect, out of existing trees — creating, in other words, a kind of giant bonsai.

It tries to sell something as completely unique. It’s not. For example this sentence should emphasize what’s unique with daisugi, because there is a very good English word with this exact same meaning as written in this sentence: grafting.

1 comments

> there is a very good English word with this exact same meaning as written in this sentence: grafting.

Grafting is joining cuttings from one tree to a rootstock of another. That is not what's going on here at all, it's limited to a single tree.

Something like "selective pollarding", maybe, but that's very far from being a common English word. And as I said, most pollarding I have seen is nowhere as straight and tall as this.

Exactly. Which you cannot possibly know from the cited sentence.