Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by gucci-on-fleek 1 hour ago
What do you recommend instead? Standard floating-point ("float"/"double"), fixed-point arithmetic with thousandths (or smaller) of the minor unit, arbitrary-precision decimal numbers, or something else entirely?
4 comments

I think what matters most is your database and API representation, as well as having consistent and well-defined rounding rules.

I largely agree with TFA: Round explicitly and consistently whenever you cross a boundary, i.e. database persistence and internal API calls.

Use whatever works for your required business case internally (i.e. inside of procedures calculating some function of one or more input amounts). This can be regular old floats/doubles if you absolutely know what you're doing, or BigDecimal if you aren't and would rather suffer slightly slower performance than having to talk to an auditor about IEEE 754 rounding modes, or even minor-amount integers (yes, even though I just said to not use them – but you'll want to ABSOLUTELY NEVER leak them outside of your system, including your data/analytics pipeline, which might have different ideas about financial amounts than your business logic implementing a nice custom monetary type).

A string type. As parent says: it completely bypasses the problem. Save the numbers between double quotes and be done with it.
Storing numbers as arrays of u8? That doesn't make sense
For JSON serialization, which doesn't support fixed-point precision it does.

Floating-point precision has too many gotchas for being suitable to store Decimal types, especially for the Currency use case.

Do not throw away any precision in finance/money computation, regardless what/ how you are doing it.

In C# e.g., there is type decimal for those computations.

You'll definitely have to throw it away at some point.

The art is in making those points well-defined and rare enough to not cause large discrepancies, but frequent enough to avoid ballooning arbitrary-precision numbers across databases and services that might not be able to handle them.

I really like that phrasing! Would you mind if I steal in some form if I decide to review this part of the book?
Floating point value stored multiplied by 10^8. That gives you a huge integer, but it's extremely accurate, especially for US denominated currencies. Easily transformed into floating point numbers for reporting/etc.