Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by suddenlybananas 4 hours ago
Scrolls from Herculaneum have been read for a very long time. Not disputing the achievement of digitally unrolling one, but the scrolls from the library of have been studied since the 18th century.
3 comments

I think it's a case of HN once again butchering the title. I submitted it as the exact title from our page on scrollprize.org, "An _Entire_ Herculaneum Scroll Has Been Read For The First Time", which is IIRC true.
Ok, I've restored the entire title above. Sorry about that!

(Btw, you can use the 'edit' link to fix things like this if the software gets a title change wrong.)

*Some scrolls.

They are in a variety of conditions - some of them people were able to "break" open and read. But the vast majority of what remains is too delicate and brittle to risk.

Sure, but its the potential scale that is important. There are also more scrolls still in the ground, which would make sense to dig out if they could be read.
Of course! But the title is misleading and gives people the impression that we don't already know the library is just full of Epicurean texts.
It's also technically incorrect. The texts have been read; this particular text was read for the first time in the modern era.