Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jmyeet 1 hour ago
Many people seem to think racism begins and ends with using a slur. You can usually get a measure of this by seeing someone's reaction to the statement:

> There is no such thing as anti-white racism.

If you find yourself wanting to disagree with that then, I'm sorry but you simply don't know what racism is. Racism is pervasive, insidious and systemic.

A good example in the hiring space is what's called the "second syllable name problem". Traditionally Afrcian names often stress the second syllable (eg Jamal, Lakisha, Malik, Lashonda). Studies have shown that such names have higher rejection rates in job applications [1]. So if you're wondering about the four-fifths rule, it's because it exposes this kind of bias. It's not proof of bias. It simply means further investigation is required.

The problem with AI hiring tools is the logic is opaque. You have no idea why an AI system is rejecting or selecting candidates and you may find it's doing something illegal. Some companies want to hide behind this opaqueness, arguing that if no explicit decision was made then there is no bias. But that's not how system racism works.

There are many such signals that correlate with race that if they affect selection rate, it could be a problem. Did you go to an HBCU? Was your high school in a minority-majority area? What about your previous employers?

This kind of bias doesn't have to be intentional.

[1]: https://www.npr.org/2024/04/11/1243713272/resume-bias-study-...

2 comments

> > There is no such thing as anti-white racism.

> If you find yourself wanting to disagree with that then, I'm sorry but you simply don't know what racism is.

You are saying that if you think anti-white racism can exist, you don't know what racism is. That's obviously ludicrous.

I’m sorry, this is catechism. Everyone deserves a fair shot, but you can’t expect the world to follow this liturgical logic.