Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by locknitpicker 3 hours ago
> "Using GET with a Body works"

Except it doesn't. Some API gateways outright strip request bodies from GET requests to prevent them from being forwarded.

It sounds like most people with the "just use GET" nonsense are far from having any experience in cloud computing.
1 comments
topham 2 hours ago
QUERY won't be supported by them either.

So, change is required. Just change GET to allow for body and move on.

Most of the systems that are blocking GET/body could be easily tweaked to allow it. Today. As is.

QUERY will likely need firmware updates, core engine updates, etc.

Meanwhile, tweaking GET is a rule change.

link
akersten 20 minutes ago
Yeah I really don't understand the anti-GET-body argument.

"Using GET with a body isn't in the spec, WAFs and webservers that haven't been updated might reject it!"

Ok, QUERY wasn't in the spec when those were written either. What do you expect those appliances to do with a totally unknown verb?

It's a welcome addition but the new method is pure marketing. There's no reason the update couldn't have been to expand GET instead of add support for QUERY.

link