[s0ibeanz]

What we have today isn't insurance in any meaningful sense. Traditional insurance is about pricing risk: healthier people pay less, higher-risk people pay more, and the pool works because premiums reflect actuarial reality.

The Affordable Care Act largely banned that. Insurers can no longer use health status or pre-existing conditions to set rates (via "community rating" and guaranteed issue rules). The result is that everyone effectively pays into a giant, heavily regulated pool. There's a finite amount of money in that pool, so someone has to ration care. That job now falls to the insurance companies, who deny or delay procedures, medications, and treatments.

Health insurers aren't saints — but the core problem is structural. When you remove risk pricing while mandating coverage, adverse selection and cost shifting are inevitable. The ACA patched one serious issue (pre-existing conditions) by breaking the fundamental mechanism that makes insurance sustainable.

We need to be honest about the tradeoffs instead of pretending this is still "insurance."

[amanaplanacanal]

It makes sense. People don't want insurance, they want health care.