Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ggm 2 days ago
The low bar path out for Iran is not to charge US ships insurance. The people most likely to complain would not complain if America has an exception.
5 comments

Does anything America imports through the Strait travel on U.S.-flagged vessels?
The US import very little from Hormuz on any ship. Most buy ers are in asia or europe.
If the only recourse is to spend tens of billions on another bombing campaign, or even more on a land war, why would Iran be looking for a path out of anything?
Americans are fueled by spite, though.
Spite against whom? Like most Americans, I have a number of grave concerns about the Iranian regime and the terrible things they've done. But on a personal level, Donald Trump has done a lot more to make me feel spiteful than either Masoud Pezeshkian or Mojtaba Khamenei have. I think everyone involved is well aware of this fact and it's going to continue to severely constrain Trump's options.
Americans have zero concerns about Iran, they care more about inflation and gas prices, it is evident in all surveys.

the only people who have grave concerns over Iran are the ones who have monetary incentive to do so, or ethnical tribalism reason

It sounds like you agree with me that Americans do not feel that fighting theocracy in Iran is a particularly high priority, and that people who care about it care more about domestic issues. So I'm not sure why you've chosen to express that in such a confrontational tone. Perhaps I've misunderstood something.
>>Like most Americans, I have a number of grave concerns about the Iranian regime

I didn't agree with "most Americans" part. This kind of rhetoric is false and is used to whitewash and launder war crimes and escape responsibility, for example for murdering 160 Iranian school girls in in Minab.

I see
It affects global prices and sets a precedent against rules on international waters and freedom of navigation.
What does it tell us that current leadership in Washington lacks the credibility to make that argument? The tariffs and threats to sovereignty of our erstwhile allies have already damaged international norms at least as much as closing the straight of Hormuz.
There is zero commercial shipping through the Strait with US flags, everybody uses flags of convenience.
The US could also get into this racket then by offering US ship registrations at a very reasonable price...
> US ships

What US ships?