Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rcbdev 42 days ago
Please read Directive (EU) 2022/2557 and then tell me how a disgruntled office worker is supposed to do anything they aren't supposed to, given full compliance with the directive. I've seen some preliminary national implementation efforts and it's really serious stuff physical security wise.

https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CEL...
1 comments
eqvinox 42 days ago
> full compliance with the directive

I don't think I've ever seen a place fully compliant with all regulations down to the last letter. Somebody inevitably takes a shortcut somewhere. All you can do is push those shortcuts into places they don't matter.

Certainly not the times and culture we live in, but the "test" they tried running at Chornobyl violated their own regulations too…

link
gambiting 42 days ago
But again:

>>highly radioactive material is within reach of any disgruntled office worker.

Like, how would that disgruntled office worker even reach that highly radioactive material? Especially without killing themselves in the process. Hospitals already have extremely radioactive cobalt sources on premises, and they are 1) impossible to get to by a normal employee 2) would kill said employee if they ever did get to them somehow.

link
RetroTechie 41 days ago
There can be a good bit of time between receiving a lethal dose of radiation, and dying (or incapacitated) from that.

Also sources tend to come with shielding. Some portable, some less-portable. Oh and.. use machinery / robots / whatever, with operator outside the danger zone.

Your "impossible" does a lot of heavy lifting here.

link
gambiting 41 days ago
>> impossible to get to by a normal employee

No, it's the normal that does the heavy lifting. A radiation therapy machine does not allow for an easy removal of the source, not without hours of work with specialized machinery. Again, how does a disgruntled office worker do this without immediate attention of security?

>>There can be a good bit of time between receiving a lethal dose of radiation, and dying (or incapacitated) from that

Well, it's really unfortunate, but we have multiple reports from people who have accidentally walked into a room with an open Cesium source at various irradiation facilities - they all reported that they felt incredibly sick in less than a minute. And that's "just" an irradiation source, not an active nuclear reactor. Again, I'm struggling to imagine how a "disgruntled worker" gets anywhere near the actual radiactive material within it.

link