Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by kmeisthax 10 hours ago
I don't live in Belgium, and you probably don't want me, a filthy American, living in Belgium. However, I can confidently say what problem you're bumping up against:

Your government does not know how to integrate foreigners.

America used to have an extremely racist and restrictive immigration policy. This was only undone about 50 years ago. As part of the deracialization of American immigration, a bunch of racist senators decided to give America an extremely generous family sponsorship program, specifically to keep the immigrant pool as white as possible. This backfired horribly (for them, not me): America became one of the easiest countries for people from poor countries to immigrate to, because we outsourced the question of who to admit to people who already knew who they are. This derisked the immigration process and resulted in more immigrants from more countries. So every major American city[0] has a pool of well-adjusted, fully integrated immigrants now.

Europe did... none of this. The immigration policy most countries in Europe has is tailored specifically for bringing in temporary workers that can be dismissed as will[2]. This selects for low-skilled rural migrants, and a random sample of those from any country will give you people who are more conservative than average. In contrast, America's relatively liberalized immigration policy means we're taking in migrants from all walks of life.

The proof of this is borne out in opinion polling of EU-external immigrants. For example, Turks who move to America have political opinions about Erdogan in line with the American mainstream - that is to say, they hate him as much as I do, if not more. Turks who move to Germany support Erdogan even more than Turks that did not emigrate.

To make matters worse, this property is self-perpetuating. A random immigrant from one of these countries will fall back upon their local diaspora population for support. In America that means making friends with people from all walks of life. In Germany that means joining an illegal far-right[1] Turkish biker gang.

The problem Europe has right now is not entirely foreign to American history. The restrictive, racist immigration policy America used to have was itself a reaction to the time in which America's immigration policy was "lol"[3]. Immigration used to be a matter of showing up to Ellis Island and answering a few questions. A crop failure and famine in Ireland, as well as widespread poverty in Sicily, triggered two huge waves of crisis migration to a country that had little Italian or Irish already. This naturally triggered a crime wave, followed by a white backlash that resulted in the nadir of American race relations and the passage of those racist policies.

Not that far off from Europe today, right? But at the same time, it's proof that this is a solvable problem, because America already solved it. We saw the problems with having a large Italian and Irish underclass and implemented programs and policies specifically to include and integrate them. The result is... nobody cares. The organized crime that followed the immigrants died out because we smothered it in a blanket of good job opportunities and inclusion programs. Unless you're teaching a New York State history class, you might not even know about any of this. America doesn't have a racial barrier between Irish or Italian immigrants and the rest of the country anymore. They're just... there.

[0] As a European you are probably arguing that America does not have cities because of our comically awful public transportation networks. That is true, but New York City is both the heavy rail capital of the country and the immigration capital of the country, so...

[1] In case this isn't obvious: the Muslims taking over your country are just as worried about western culture taking over theirs. Far-right ideology requires an other that has also adopted (or is perceived to adopt) the same far-right ideology with the labels swapped.

[2] To be clear, America also has visa programs that do this. Those are the ones the Mexican cartels are abusing; because they're designed to create a legal and economic niche for slave labor and human trafficking.

[3] Unless you were Asian. Fun fact: South Asians used to actually pretend to be black in order to avoid this!