Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dingaling 9 days ago
> A pyramid scheme can run out of people to keep it going

And then you describe how the secondary stock market requires 'fresh blood' to whom to sell stock to cash-out.

It's precisely a legalised pyramid scheme that always needs someone to come in at the bottom hold the bag to let someone else cash-out. In turn they need someone to come in 30 years later. That's exactly how a pyramid scheme works.

1 comments

> In turn they need someone to come in 30 years later. That's exactly how a pyramid scheme works.

The entire economy is a pyramid scheme: the expenses of some people (shelter, food, clothing, entertainment, etc) are the income of other people (landlords/mortgages/property taxes, farmers/grocers, etc). It's why, during economic downturns, personal virtues (saving) can become vices from macroeconomic perspective: if everyone is saving, no one is spending, and so producers/suppliers lose their income (and generally start laying people off, which causes more saving / less spending).

At any given point in time, if no one spends, then no one has income.

This was the 'innovation' of Keynes in the 1930s: use government spending to 'induce' demand to get the cycle going again:

* https://archive.nytimes.com/krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/0...

For a stocks point of view: if no one is currently saving, then those that need income will lose it. At any given point there are folks who need to save/buy and those that need to spend/sell.

Exchange of goods with money isn’t a pyramid scheme imo. Financial system is a pyramid scheme, economy isn’t
A typical pyramid/Ponzi scheme falls apart when (new) people stop putting money into the system.

What happens to the economy when people stop putting into the system (by saving, and not spending on goods/services)?