Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by belmarca 46 days ago
Yes, definitely the case. Just imagine a class with 100 students, each with a system that has its own quirks (OS, browser, and a mix of versions, etc). We built codeBoot (https://codeboot.org) specifically for this reason!
2 comments

In my experience you can just tell AI to install it and it will figure out all of those quirks on its own.
We started this project before LLMs were popularized :) And surprisingly enough, experience says a lot of students would get stuck anyway.
I hate to second the grandparent, but perhaps the install process is the most difficult part for the instructor because it is at a stage where the instructor feels 90% responsible for the outcomes.

A criticism like “I didn’t understand recursive functions” is a student problem. A criticism like “the instructions to install the environment never worked” is much more clearly a problem of the instructions. Even if, as you said, there are subtleties.

I will maintain that the only way the install process is actually the most difficult part for the student is if they are already a competent programmer. Which seems unlikely for a class like this.

OK, sure the concepts might be harder than setting up an environment. But setting things up is, by experience, a very real, very annoying and time-consuming blocker. We have students come in with tablets and it "just works"!