Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by nradov 3 days ago
And yet the EU legislature seems to be actively hostile to some human rights, such as the right to free expression and the right to keep and bear arms. How do you account for that discrepancy?
1 comments

European countries have higher freedom of press than the US. Bearing arms is not a human right in Europe, different culture.

Europe has more human rights protections than the US and stronger enforcement of them, even against the state, by many metrics. Freedom of expression ends where other human rights begin, is protecting hate speech and Holocaust denial really something worthwhile?

So are you claiming that human rights are subjective and not universal? Or that it's acceptable for the EU to violate human rights if the USA is worse in some ways?

Belarus is a European country. How is freedom of the press doing there?

I don’t know why you think the American definition of human rights is universal?

It is. Look at the freedom of press index for example. And as the US doesn’t accept foreign courts, there is not really a legal apparatus against the state outside of the US, which many European countries do have.

Belarus is not part of the EU, nor did it sign many of the international human rights

I don't know why you think the EU definition of human rights matters at all?

The comment I responded to was about Europe. Belarus is part of Europe. As are Serbia, Moldova, etc.

It does matter, for example for all countries that signed the ECHR. And most European countries even have more rights guaranteed by the state and by EU.

You are trying to move goalposts instead of trying to counter my arguments

It's doing fine