Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by gilleain 1 day ago
I meant metallocenes in general:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metallocene

A metal atom sandwiched between two Cp rings. You _can_ model this as 5 single bonds between each atom of a ring (so 10 total C-M bonds), or you have to have some kind of 'edge' (bond) between the ring as a whole and the metal.

The more general issue is that a graph model of a chemical assumes a 'bond' is between exactly two atoms. Three-center hydrogen bonds are another example where this model fails to capture the chemistry very well.

Of course, it's a tradeoff - you can model _most_ compounds with just graphs (plus atom type, charge, chirality) and the relatively few that do not quite fit are special cases.

1 comments

From what I found, current state of the art on modelling "reaction space" with graphs that is to use "hypergraphs" where edges can lead to more than one node[^0].

But I am just someone who got curious; not even an amateur ^^’

[0]: https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jcim.5c00265