Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dindunuf 3 days ago
prompt any Western model to write an offensive joke about any minority.
4 comments

The fact that your username is a racist meme seems relevant to this complaint and how legitimate it is.
That’s not quite the same as censoring information, though.
ask any Western model to tell you how to 3D print a gun.
Is the idea that instructions to make weapons, and learning about history are comparable?
Censorship is censorship.
Is it? Would bioweapon instruction restrictions be equivalent to disallowing reporting on whether the government is massacring large numbers of citizens in your city? Both are ‘censorship’ but don’t seem remotely equivalent to me.
That’s the thing about principled positions. If you believe censorship is wrong, then it is equally wrong no matter what the topic is.
I should think learning about history should lead to a desire for citizens to be able to quietly make weapons at home given the many documented cases of governments across the world mass murdering their own citizens (or foreign governments invading and genociding). What's the point of telling people the wrongs of their oppressors while simultaneously disempowering them from doing anything about it or preparing to defend themselves in the future?

So yes they're not just comparable, but two sides of the same coin.

The idea that Chinese citizens could’ve prevented the Tiananmen massacre with a bunch of home printed AK-47s is silly. The government had tanks. The same applies in the US.
50/50 chance Grok will do it even if you ask it not to.
Grok and mistral will do it no problem.