Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Imnimo 49 days ago
No, he asked for the government to make the decision in light of 3rd party analysis. Which is what happened here - an independent company demonstrated a jailbreak, and the government issued a restriction on deployment based on that finding.
2 comments
llelouch 49 days ago
"The government should have the power to block or deter deployment of the model if it is determined, in light of third-party assessment, to present unacceptable risks. This power must be scoped to the above four specific risks and there must be protective measures against political favoritism or arbitrary decisions."

You are wrong.

Read in full here https://darioamodei.com/post/policy-on-the-ai-exponential.

I know you won't though. haha.

link
Imnimo 49 days ago
I am having trouble understanding which ingredient you feel is missing here.

Can you be more specific? It seems to me that the there was a third party assessment, they identified risks associated with the specific risk groups, and the government therefore chose to block the model's deployment.

link
varenc 47 days ago
The goverment used the existing ITAR laws to block the 'export' of the model to anyone not a US citizen. This is quite onerous to enforce, since it applies to non-citizens physically in the US. So Anthropic shutdown access completely, as the only reasonable solution.

The key point is the government used ITAR. What's being asked for by Dario (and many others) is some entirely new legal process with more involvement and balances that blocks the model for everyone explicitly. But apparently just enforcing ITAR is good enough to do effectively the same thing.

link
vessenes 49 days ago
You have to be precise: the gov blocked “export” of the model (search for ITAR for a lengthy history on this), and Anthropic picked up its ball and went home.

I’m willing to bet internally they thought this was a good plan from the beginning - from engagement, requests for reg oversight, Mythos PR, silently nerfing AI engineering quality, and now this “pulling the model” stunt. It’s frustrating, I generally like using the Claude models, but I don’t think I’ve ever been a customer of such a user-hostile company before.

link
theshrike79 49 days ago
So if I can demonstrate a jailbreak in ChatGPT, the government will immediately slap a "no foreign nationals" ban on GPT-5.5?
link